//, Parties for Boys, Theme Parties/Creative Mr. Potato Head Pirate Party

Creative Mr. Potato Head Pirate Party

Quick Jump To » Vendor Credits | Comments

spud potato bar

Stop for BAARGH-B-Q eats or Walk the Plank at this Creative Mr. Potato Head Pirate Party! Mom, Cineca of Dreamin’ N Details threw “Captain Lennon” a fourth birthday full of swords, hooks, nets and golden treasure with a unique spud inspired spin!

PARTY HIGHLIGHTS to look out for:

  • ‘Build your own Spud’ Bar with yummy toppings: shredded cheese, bacon bits, sour cream, & ranch
  • Mr. Potato Head cake pops & pirate themed Oreo fondant toppers
  • Pirate punch (for the kids) & Rum Punch (for the adults)
  • ‘Pin the Pieces on the Potato Head’ game
  • Eye patch, pirate mask & a treasure chest favor box full of candy gold coins

walk the plank diy sign

potato pirate dessert table

potato head pirate cake pops

simple pirate birthday cake

rainbow birthday cake

pirate desserts

potato bar pirate party

mr potato head pirate party

pirate party punch

pirate mask

potato head activity


PARTY DETAILS, as told by Cineca

My son’s first toy was a Mr. Potato Head and he has loved them ever since. For his 4th Birthday he was set on being a pirate. I loved the idea of a Pirate themed party, but I wanted to put a unique spin on it. I combined his love of Mr. Potato Head with his desire to be a pirate…and Wah-Lah…Mr Potato the Pirate was born.

I wanted to play on the traditional pirate colors (red, white & black) but also add some bold Mr Potato Head colors (blue, green, yellow.) I made the red & white striped table runners, and used a basic color palette of black linens and white overlays for the dessert, food, and kid’s tables.

For decorations, I raided the Halloween sections of my local Party City, Dollar Tree, and Target. I used gold coins, beaded necklaces, eye patches, gold candy, and bandanas as ‘pirate booty.’ Skeletons, swords, hooks, netting, Potato Heads dressed as pirates, and even a parrot were used as focal points in the decor. Many talented party friends created amazing works of art for the party; including Kandy Kones by Superchick Studios, pirate peg dolls from Crossing the Bugger-Dixon Line, mini cake banners from Truly Chic Inspirations, and cupcake wrappers for the petit four ‘treasure cups’ by Creative Juice. The custom printables (invitation, banners, food tents, and labels) were designed by Piggy Bank Parties.

What’s a Mr Potato Head party without a ‘Build Your Own Spud’ Bar?! There were potatoes and all of the yummy toppings: shredded cheese, bacon bits, sour cream, and ranch dressing. Along with the potatoes, we served our favorite BBQ. There were smoked chicken & pulled pork sliders, BBQ Baked Beans, and of course, Pirate Punch (a kid friendly version and a Rum Punch for the adults.)

My sweet lil pirate loves goodies as much as the next pirate, but I usually keep the sweet treats to a minimum…except on his birthday! We had so many wonderful sweets. Fondant Topped Oreos, Pirate Petit Fours served on treasure cups, a Tie-Dyed Birthday Cake, custom Fondant Mr Potato Pirates, and Mr Potato Pirate Cake Pops.

Since it was a yucky, rainy day and the party had to be moved inside, we kept the kiddos busy with a fun game of Pin the Pieces on the Potato Head. We created a large Potato Head out of cardboard and attached velcro to the pieces. The kids were blind-folded and had to attach the pieces in the correct positions. That game was almost as much fun to watch as it was to play.

Each lil pirate took home an eye patch, pirate mask, and a treasure chest favor box full of candy gold coins & bars.

Vendor Credit
By |2017-03-09T15:14:33+00:00January 10th, 2013|Kids Birthday, Parties for Boys, Theme Parties|

About the Author:

Hi, I’m Alyssa, and I love seeing all the inspiration on HWTM! Aside for my obvious love of design, parties, and blogging, here are a few random things about me…

1. I’ve done 3 triathlons.

2. I just got married on 3.14.15

3. I’m from Miami, Florida.

4. My 4 favorite Hostess INK collections are Birthday-saurus, Farm birthday, Baby Bistro, and Retro Rainbow.

5. I love to cook but hardly, if ever, repeat dinner recipes.


  1. invitation consultants January 10, 2013 at 6:48 am

    ADORABLE idea!

  2. Mejia Mamma January 10, 2013 at 9:14 am

    SO cute…where did you get those pirate hat/eye masks?!

    • Cineca Newburn January 23, 2013 at 12:05 pm

      Thank you Mejia,
      The pirate masks are from Hobby Lobby :)

  3. […] N Details walked the plank for her son’s 4th birthday and ended up with a feature on Hostess with the Mostess. Honored to be a part of this “mash up” of Pirates and Mr. Potato […]

  4. chrissyenglish June 6, 2013 at 10:41 am

    Pirate themed parties are my favorite! Here is a link to some cute favor bags that would add to this party:)

  5. Stephanie September 18, 2013 at 2:45 am


    Where can I get your Mr Potato image?

  6. Brandi November 24, 2013 at 1:32 pm

    Where can I find the pirate mr potatoe heads?

  7. […] got a gift – and Lynlee North Beckett is the perfect example! From miniature Disneyland rides to Mr. Potato Head pirates, her incredible fondant work has been popping up in the parties we’ve featured here at HWTM […]

  8. […] Image via Hostess with the Mostess […]

Comments are closed.